Dear Bo,
Thank you for reaching back out. My apologies for not getting back to you on this over the summer too. I’ve just been overwhelmed.
I did send out feelers across NIST to our DNA and genomic standards folks, but I do not believe I ever heard a specific answer. I will follow up on this.
One of the questions I have, having read the paper when it was published so it’s not fresh in my mind, is whether you are thinking about an actual product being sold, or a documentary standard that says “buy these DNAs, run them this way, this should be your result.”
My memory is that the shelf life and easy obtainability of (exactly) identical materials seemed to be potential issues for either scenario.
It is also likely in either case that if the material is intended solely for AUC that the person may be me, or Chris Sims, who is my project team member currently doing most of our AUC experiments. Chris will be at the meeting in Philly next month and hopefully at the AUC meeting (the budget is tough this FY and my chance of attending seems very close to 0).
For some context, NIST has become very stingy about issuing new actual reference materials in recent years, but commercially reproducible materials can also serve as a basis for documentary standards. Regardless, a likely activity would include conducting a two+ round interlaboratory comparison demonstrating that first a single source of the material yields reproducible results across labs, and then that independently acquired (or additional production batches depending) also yield consistent results (within some uncertainty, which is essentially being codetermined). There is a goodly amount of effort that goes into both paths.
As a path forward, I suggest we have a zoom meeting next week. Monday from 1-4 EST, Wednesday 1-2:30 EST or Thurs 2-4 EST are all open windows if one of those works on your end.
Best,
Jeff
From: Borries Demeler <demeler@gmail.com>
Sent: Wednesday, January 24, 2024 6:39 PM
To: Fagan, Jeffrey A. Dr. (Fed) <jeffrey.fagan@nist.gov>
Subject: NIST standards
Hello Jeff,
I hope this email finds you well!
I wanted to pick up on our conversation during AUC 2022 about the molecular standards. We are looking for a collaborator at NIST who would be able to help us provide some guidance on the development of a molecular standard for AUC. We have what I believe to be a pretty good plan, and I was wondering if you would be interested in this. If so, I propose we have a zoom call with the student developing this project and go from there?
best wishes, -Borries