Branch: refs/heads/somo-dev Home: https://github.com/ehb54/ultrascan3 Commit: 7da8a315fa7ef14a7830927cdef90989f72fc445 https://github.com/ehb54/ultrascan3/commit/7da8a315fa7ef14a7830927cdef90989f... Author: Emre Brookes <emre.brookes@umontana.edu> Date: 2026-08-15 (Sat, 15 Aug 2026) Changed paths: M us_somo/develop/grpy/grpy_shell.hpp Log Message: ----------- somo/grpy: raise the shell-reduction error floor to 0.75 of the raw gap The estimate is max(safety * Richardson remainder, floor * raw inter-rung gap). Validating the full 23-model grid with all five observables -- the previous multi-observable grid ran only 12 of the 23 models, so eleven never had intrinsic viscosity or rotational diffusion checked -- exposed two evaluations that passed the estimator's stop test yet missed the requested tolerance (2GD1 intrinsic viscosity at 1%: estimate 0.859%, true error 1.066%), plus eleven more that were compliant but undercovered. Tolerance compliance is a subset of estimator coverage: the ladder stops when the estimate falls below the tolerance, so an estimate that covers the true error makes stopping imply compliance. Verified on the grid -- no row missed its tolerance while covered, and all 235 reduced rows converged. Raising the floor rather than `safety` is deliberate. The two terms are combined with max(), so while the floor binds the safety factor does nothing: with a doubling ladder and the order at k_max = 3 the remainder is gap/7, and safety * gap/7 stays under 0.5 * gap for any safety <= 3.5. Measured on the same grid, safety = 2.0 fixed neither failure and drove the median case to retain every bead, because it inflates the estimate for the well-behaved majority where the floor is slack. The floor acts only on the high-observed-order rows that fail. At 0.75 the grid is clean: 200/200 reduced evaluations inside their tolerance and all 200 covered, worst case spending 55.3% of the allowed budget (was 106.6%), for 4.6 percentage points more beads retained on average. floor_frac is exposed on ShellOptions rather than left hardcoded, alongside k_min, k_max and safety. Measuring it required patching a private copy of this header, and a second copy of an estimator is what makes validation results unattributable. The file's own MEASURED note claimed 92/92 and 252/252; both were wrong (seven observables counted, three research-only; and the narrow model grid). Corrected to what this code actually returns -- the finest rung, not the extrapolation. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> Commit: 69e372e6764e086a32759607f45e67c2831da51f https://github.com/ehb54/ultrascan3/commit/69e372e6764e086a32759607f45e67c28... Author: emre brookes <ehb54@users.noreply.github.com> Date: 2026-08-15 (Sat, 15 Aug 2026) Changed paths: M us_somo/develop/grpy/grpy_shell.hpp Log Message: ----------- Merge pull request #515 from ehb54/ehb54-984-floor somo/grpy: raise the shell-reduction error floor to 0.75 of the raw gap Compare: https://github.com/ehb54/ultrascan3/compare/8423eafd59f9...69e372e6764e To unsubscribe from these emails, change your notification settings at https://github.com/ehb54/ultrascan3/settings/notifications