Branch: refs/heads/ehb54-issue-920 Home: https://github.com/ehb54/ultrascan3 Commit: fdf85a3561ea2a81545442e018d2402c0b912a51 https://github.com/ehb54/ultrascan3/commit/fdf85a3561ea2a81545442e018d2402c0... Author: ehb54 <brookes@uthscsa.edu> Date: 2026-07-21 (Tue, 21 Jul 2026) Changed paths: M us_somo/develop/src/us_hydrodyn_saxs_iqq_extrap_c0.cpp M us_somo/somo/doc/manual/somo/somo_saxs_extrap_c0.html Log Message: ----------- extrap_c0: report per-curve I(0)/c diagnostic (surface evidence, not a verdict) Closes out the reference-quality question. Two candidate automatic checks were built and tested first, and both failed: - a residual-derived sigma(q) as the regularization noise model: on simulated series swept from 4 to 32 concentrations it never beat the existing weighting, and did not improve with more curves, so the failure was not degrees of freedom. - a high-q shape veto for reference quality: on simulated series with defects injected into the top curve it separated only a constant buffer-subtraction offset (8.7x), and missed mis-set concentration, aggregation and damage entirely (0% of seeds). Worse, the statistic tracks signal-to-noise, which rises with concentration, so in the CLEAN case the top curve scores best of the set (0.093 vs 0.145) -- a veto built on it is biased against ever firing. Both fail for the same structural reason: the highest-concentration curve is at once the highest-leverage point in the regression and the highest-SNR curve, so it looks good by every measure available from inside the series. The information is not there. So report the evidence instead of guessing. Each run now logs, per curve, the Guinier Rg and I(0), the ratio I(0)/c, and its deviation from (a) the series median and (b) the trend predicted by the OTHER curves. I(0)/c is constant in the dilute limit and falls smoothly as the interparticle term grows, so a curve off the others indicates a mis-set concentration or aggregation. The trend column is leave-one-out, so the curve cannot pull the line onto itself -- the only form of this comparison that says anything about the extreme concentration. Deviations beyond 15% are highlighted. Nothing is discarded or re-selected on this basis; it feeds the reference selector, which the user drives. On the 7-curve alpha-syn set this independently reproduces Mattia's assessment of the 0.694246 curve (+12.2% vs trend, i.e. the overestimated MW he reports). It does NOT reproduce his call on 2.41176, which sits at -5.9% and is unremarkable by either measure. Verified: all 9 regression baselines byte-identical (the diagnostic is log-only) and the table is emitted on all 9 runs. Manual updated. Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com> To unsubscribe from these emails, change your notification settings at https://github.com/ehb54/ultrascan3/settings/notifications